Leonidas
Posts: 2078
Joined: 2/16/2004 Status: offline
|
quote:
That is so incredibly fascinating...and quite common amongst early religious texts. Modifications to the original holy text by prophets was a common strategy used by one group to change the direction (in other words, take control) of a religion. Different time, different motivation. Nobody that I know of is producing electronic copies of the books in order to take control of the "religion". The motivation is simple larceny. The books are readily available on the second hand market, but it's pretty expensive to amass a set (many of them go for 25 dollars or more). Electronic copies of the books are passed around for the same reason that electronic music gets passed around; to keep from paying for it. You will find web sites out there with "quotes" from the books that don't actually appear in the books. These are usually created by role-players who have never seen the books, and who posted the "quote" to validate how they role-play, probably in response to someone telling them that what they're doing isn't authentic. You will also see quotes from the books that have been carefully excised out of context to prove some claim or another about what "real Goreans" do, again, to prove or disprove the authenticity of what someone is doing in a role-play chatroom. That is about as close to the "false-prophet" syndrome that you describe as I have seen. What we do won't ever be a religion. What religions all have in common is that they deal with what happens after you die. Those that posit that anything happens after you die prescribe a set of behaviors that, presumably, will lead to a better outcome for you after death, whether you move on to some other form of existance or are reborn into this one. Regardless of what you may or may not think about religions, living Gorean isn't one. It only deals with the here-and-now, not the hereafter. The only folks who get wrapped around the axel about what the books do or don't say, or whether "Urth" appears or not are role-players, who tend to get passionate about how authentic their play is (or, more accurately, how authentic the other guy's play isn't). Those kinds of debates don't really have much relevance to those of us who live this way, since we aren't trying to adopt a role-play persona that emulates characters in the novels.
< Message edited by Leonidas -- 9/6/2005 6:18:39 AM >
_____________________________
Take care of yourself Leonidas
|