Elisabella
Posts: 3939
Joined: 5/22/2008 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Musicmystery quote:
Was Augustine a theologian, or a philosopher? They are not mutually exclusive, of course, any more than all scientists must be religious or not. I agree completely. quote:
People throw around terms loosely, ignoring that much of our language is metaphor, citing it as if specific. To say "Science is my religion," for example, is metaphoric, and while Scientologists can call themselves anything they wish, it's neither a science nor a religion in any true sense. Two complete agreements in a row...*checks for a full moon* quote:
Look, for example, at the many books and articles titled "The Science of _______" that have nothing at all to do with science as a discipline (in the sense scientists would use the term). Nods. The Science of Astrology and The Science of Feng Shui comes to mind...not sure if they're real books but you get the point. As neither uses the scientific method, it would be more apt to call them "the discipline of" or "the method of" but ironically enough, they use "science of" to make it sound more valid. quote:
The problem again comes from those unable to separate the plot of fiction from its themes (as in sgs's post, and as in several silly criticisms that keep crossing this forum and probably always will). I think a lot of that is willful ignorance. Yes, the Gorean philosophy is a great way to live life, but how freaking cool is it to have a sword and chain your slave to the post of the bed and get a faux-rabbit-fur-dyed-leopard-print blanket to have sex on? And it's hard for a lot of people to say "I like this unorthodox thing for my own reasons," so they say "it's part of the philosophy" to feel like they're supported in their choice. quote:
There's also a sweeping assumption that people with similar interests would want to live together. Get together at times, talk, sure, but form a literal community? No thanks. *grins* Yeah, when you go to someone's house for drinks and talk, you know who the Ubar is. He's the guy whose chairs you're sitting on and whose beer you're drinking. A bunch of fierce individualists co-owning a plot of land seems to be a recipe for disaster. Why ruin good friendships that way? quote:
It is very difficult for many in our society to separate the importance of the process of examination from its conclusions. They want answers, and have tremendous difficulty understanding approaches based on principles and continuing exploration rather than pat answers. Yes! Exactly! IMO, comparing Sartre (or Locke, who I actually consider to be brilliant ) with the average philosophy student is no different than comparing Augustine with the average Catholic. As far as the OP goes, I realize I haven't even answered that...all I'll say is Why? Why form a Gorean religion? If "protection from government prosecution and a way to avoid taxes" is the best reason, i think you miss the point of a religion. And you probably miss the point of being Gorean too.
_____________________________
you're just an empty cage, girl if you kill the bird
|