SylvereApLeanan
Posts: 6903
Joined: 11/1/2007 From: Hell Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: FireMiko It is my opinion that the problems of Poly have very little to do with jealousy, and more to do with the fact that romantic, sexual love is supposed to be the most sacred bond of love, a love where two people merge into one whole person and where they are the most important person in the other's life..... How then can Poly work in such a context of a relationship, how can true intimacy develop if it is based on that really deep soul consuming concept. There are three logical fallacies in this paragraph alone. First, the ideas that you're presenting are not "facts." They may be what you were raised to believe or what you came to believe based on your own experiences, but they are not facts. Second, the merging into one person is based on the Platonic ideal of soulmates. It's pretty and romantic, but highly unrealistic. For one thing, I don't need another person to "complete" me. I'm perfectly capable of being a complete person all by myself, thank you very much. When I look for partners, I look for people who can complement me and each other. For another, it's highly unrealistic to expect my romantic partner to fulfill all of my emotional and sexual needs. That's a lot of pressure to put on one person and it isn't fair of me to do so. Third, wherever did you get the idea that a romantic partner is supposed to be the most important person in his/her partner's life? Any parent knows that's a load of bollocks. My children are just as important to me as my husband. For that matter, my parents are as important as my husband. I'm confident that my husband would answer the same way about me. So your entire case is based on multiple flawed assumptions and falls apart forthwith. quote:
How could that argument work if we have been told time and time again that love for our children and friends is a very different type of love than the love between lovers? You've neglected to account for those people who have multiple lovers throughout their lives, including, but not limited to multiple spouses. I acknowledge that I am able to love more than one person in the capacity of a lover and have done so. Neither of the boys I loved in highschool became my husband and my ex-husband is not the man to whom I'm currently married. Between highschool and my current marriage, I loved quite a few people. Are you saying I didn't really love them? If you are, then I can tell you you're full of crap. And there's the rub. I sincerely doubt you'll find many people who married the first person with whom they fell in love and stayed married to that person until their dying day. Most of us have several romantic partners over the course of our lives. The difference with polyamory is that I don't feel the need to choose between lovers or to leave one lover when another comes along. I can love all of them and it's not a problem as long as everyone agrees and everyone gets his/her needs met. quote:
I found the reason why one can love as many children and friends at the same time, is because those relationships are based on just being platonic. And there is no deep touching or trying to merge the bodies into one. It is strictly a love that always tries to keep the two beings separate and never crosses a line into intimacy. I call bullshit. I can tell you for a fact that my best friend and I love each other and we have a deep, emotionally intimate connection. We say "I love you" every time we talk. We don't have a sexually intimate relationship, but polyamory doesn't require that sex be part of the bond. quote:
Since Poly people believe that there is an infinite amount of love for sexual partners, like there is for someone's children and friends, does that mean that Poly people don't believe that Romantic love is the strongest love bond of all?? Are they cynical and believe that all love bonds are the same and that neither one is stronger than the other. I believe that LOVE is a sacred bond. It can be shared on multiple levels with a wide variety of people. Although they aren't the same, none of the types of love is better or stronger than another. I could no more choose one of my children over my husband than I could choose my husband over my parents. Love just doesn't work like that for me. I think it takes a cynical and small-minded person to think that one type of love is stronger than the others. quote:
There is a certain standard in our society that places romantic/sexual love as the strongest bond anyone can share with another. Just because society has brainwashed you doesn't mean you have to stay brainwashed. I choose to live according to what is best for me and my family, including my lovers, rather than base my existence on the dictates of society's slave mentality. quote:
Sorry to have rambled on my first post, but this is genuininely a confusing thing to me about Poly and I would like to hear everyone's thoughts on it and what they believe. If being Poly means that they admit that they don't believe that romantic love is the strongest bond there is and that they have a more realistic view on love. I recommend you read Opening Up: A Guide to Creating and Sustaining Open Relationships by Tristan Taormino. You'll learn a lot. quote:
Honestly I'm surprised topics like these don't pop up more on Poly forums. Since polyfolk have already done away with the presupposition that monogamy = "normal/better/the one true way", there isn't a lot of point to rehashing the debate amongst ourselves. It's only when those who are ignorant come along to ask questions and/or make prejudicial remarks that we end up delving into it. quote:
I would think this would be the biggest issue for Poly people to confront and not issues of jealousy (which of course happen in other types of relationships but are tolerated there by society) Therein lies the answer to your question. Polyfolk have far less tolerance for jealousy, yet many people aren't taught how to handle it in a constructive fashion. Coping with jealousy is usually the thing newcomers need to learn first and fastest. Those of us who have been practicing polyamory for awhile have usually learned how to manage it in our own relationships. The veterans don't start threads about how to handle jealousy nearly as often as newbies.
_____________________________
Sylverë Dark Muse Ninja Queen Resident Caelestis Cruento 30 Fluffy Points Team Troll Charter Member: VAA Posse - Get Well Soon! I'm not evil, I'm inventive.
|