quote:

ORIGINAL: nephandi

i think i just reacted to witness becouse of the slavegirl being held of the cliff sene. It is said in the books again and again that Goreans are not usualy cruel to their slaves, well there are alot more to being cruel than inflicting physical pain, emotional pain is usualy worce. And holding a slave that had done nothing wrong of a cliff and threathening to drop her was just to me unessesary cruel. Ofcourse her owners had the right, but that sene just did not match whit the rest of the eris. Often in the Gor series women is diseplined, handeld sternly or branded and done things to one might consider cruel, but all of that for a reason, the slave might not see the reason, but it is there, just like my little cat when we take her to the vet to her her shots, she might think us mean, but we have a good reason for doing it, her not becoming ill. But the cliff sene was just unessesary, perhaps becouse i am afride of hights myself.

i think there is alot of debate on the books on whatever that man held captive in Witness was Tarl or not, i am not sure myself.

quote:

ORIGINAL: fyreredsub

She enjoyed Witness and the character of Janice and wonders if the man that was being held prisoner that escaped was Tarl Cabot???