basiasubrosa
Posts: 130
Joined: 6/23/2004 Status: offline
|
There is a Chinese saying that goes: the deeper one loves, the harsher one criticizes. I sincerely apologize if people were offended by my criticism, which was certainly not intended to be harsh. I have yet to learn how to express myself accurately without the assistance of tone or face online. That said, i applaud your sentiment, Estring, and wish that more people shared as much pride and care for their own country and its reputation. I have dual citizenship (both by birth, not naturalization), divided my childhood equally between the US and Taiwan, and divided my love and loyalty between them as well. As much as i will fiercely defend the people of the US or Taiwan or China against external slander or injury, i will also be the first to point out the problems of their/my/our governments. I personally believe that it takes a stronger love and faith to doubt, to question, to face and try to resolve problems rather than pretend those problems do not exist. I also believe that it takes critical assessment and humility to improve and strengthen a country, in order to protect that pride which may hurt at first, but will benefit in the long run. Of course, others may choose to think otherwise. I prefer not to engage in 'what would the world be like if this had not happened' surmises, as there are no real answers. (Perhaps the Navajo and Sioux join forces to conquer the world? Or Nigeria revives the prowess of its ancient civilization?) That the US has contributed significantly to the wellbeing of nations and people worldwide, i do not doubt (though i might question the 'done more than any in history' assertion, but that is irrelavent). Likewise i cannot overlook the brute force the US has imposed on other nations and other people. Victory over the Nazis is not a justification for, say, training and installing ruthless dictators in Latin America, Africa, SE Asia, Middle East, etc., and playing them off to the detriment of innocent civilians caught in between forces. If anything, it is a reminder of how aggressive, self-righteous power can go very, very awry, and that we, as opponents to that kind of power, ought to proceed with caution, restraint, and honest self-reflection. Spreading freedom and democracy are noble endeavors. But there is a difference between the benign mentor who smiles gently and lends a guiding hand, and the over-eager 'leader' who crams its own legislation, corporate deals, and military bases down its followers throats. The US has done both. I laud the former with all my heart, and because of that, it hurts all the more to see the latter erode the credibility of the former. When i am finally qualified to carry a medical satchel to refugee camps around the world, i shall be a very happy person indeed if i may represent the best intentions the US has to offer with genuine pride, not contrition. <steps off wobbly soapbox> I hope this ramble has not offended anyone. Again, most humble apologies if it has. And, of course, i welcome corrections to any erroneous opinions.
|