snowleopard
Posts: 18
Joined: 8/16/2004 From: UK Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: WayHome I am not a proponent of the capitalization/lowercase thing but I do understand why it exists. I know that, "so why do people do so online?" was a rhetorical question but I am going to use this opportunity to explain anyway. WayHome I am fully aware why it's done online, I have been online for 7 years interacting in various chatrooms and message boards, it wasn't a rhetorical question at all. I was making the point that in r/t if you and I met neither you nor I would have a capital or lowercase letter emblazened on our forehead, instead we would interact and yes even ASK questions to find out more about each other. WHY is it so important to know what my orientation is BEFORE I am deemed worthy of interacting with? THAT is what annoys me about much of the online scene. I am a submissive to the man who's collar I wear, other than that I am a living breathing unique and individual person. My desire to submit to someone isn't the ONLY thing which defines me. quote:
ORIGINAL: WayHome There is a lot that you cannot do online. See the person you are speaking to for one. Use body language or facial expressions for another. They can't even remember you by your appearance like in the reasl world but must depend only on your screen name for identification. What difference does whether it is capped or not have on their ability to remember who I am? quote:
ORIGINAL: WayHome Also, you meet a LOT of people online very quickly and asking each one a ton of questions that you might not remember the answers to anyway since odds are that you will never see them again is less than ideal. Unless you are trolling for cybersex what need is there for a ton of questions in the first place unless the intent is to get to know someone? If that is the case then whether that person has a cap in their name or not is immaterial, you merely cut out ONE question, and that is whether they consider themselves dom or sub. quote:
ORIGINAL: WayHome For all of these reasons, internet culure (BDSM and otherwise) has developed a lot of tools to speed up communication and identification. Smilies are a good example. Acronyms are another. People even use fonts and colors to help distinguish themselves. Indeed it has and that is not always a good thing, particularily when it comes to BDSM. Speed things up? Uhhhh since when has that been a good idea? Again the only thing thats "speeded up" is the labeling of someone by their orentation, nothing more. quote:
ORIGINAL: WayHome Within the online scene, another one of these tools is the use of capitalization. It makes identification easy and fast and prevents people from constantly having to ask other people's disposition so that they can address them appropriately. In various chat areas it is an important tool for the smooth, efficient, and user-friendly operation of the conversations. Address them "appropriately"? Care to eloborate on what you mean by this? quote:
ORIGINAL: WayHome It can also be something else. People use it to express their submission, like not using personal pronouns to refer to themselves. People use capitals for themselves outside of normal English grammar to express just the opposite. This might be something you are comfotable with or not. If it is important to you not to be percieved as "submitting" to everyone you meet online who has a capital letter, then I support your decision not to refer to yourself in the lower case. It appears you may have entirely missed my point. Why SHOULD a lowercase letter signify submission at ALL? Let alone to any Tom Dick or Harry who can use a shift key. Why are only online dominants deemed "worthy" of a capital letter? In fact lets go a little deeper shall we? Why should the mere fact that I am a submissive imply in anyway that I would need to stand up for my rights not to be assumed willing to submit to anyone calling themselves dominant? You support my decision? Well thanks ever so... however, I shouldn't require any "support" from anyone dom or sub vanilla or lifestyle for using the correct spelling of my name or for not wanting to be defined or judged on one aspect of who I am. quote:
ORIGINAL: WayHome On the other hand, I also support the choice of moderators to boot and ban you from their discussions for failing to follow this protocol. I'm hoping this explanation can help you to also accept their choices in this regard. Where did I say that I didn't support their right to boot me? Frankly I use it as a litmus test, if I am booted or asked to change the way my name is written and no discussion of this is allowed, then that is not a place I would be comfortable in anyway. quote:
ORIGINAL: WayHome I hope it will help you to be more understanding the next time someone makes the very reasonable assumption that you are portraying yourself as dominant by using capitals in your name and addresses you accordingly. You know I tried very hard to overlook the somewhat patronising tone of your entire post, it does however seem to illustrate perfectly the very points I am making. Did you even take the time to read my profile? Visit my site? Find out anything more about me and my experiences online and offline before you chose to answer my post and make such sweeping assumptions? What makes you assume that I am not understanding of people who address me as a dominant? What leads you to assume that when spoken to in chatrooms and asked to change that I don't very reasonably take the time to explain why I won't be changing it? In fact what led you to presume I know nothing about online protocol? Had you actually avoided the shortcuts you would have seen many articles on my site addressing this topic of online protocols in some depth. That is one of the reasons why I do feel strongly about it the net encourages people to take shortcuts, speed things up, make it "easier" and that leads to laziness. A great deal of what is good about the lifestyle is the fact that we should take the time to actually get to know people and not rush into labling them and defining them as either one thing or another. I'm a sub who won't lowercase her name, whatelse do you know about me?
_____________________________
~submission is something inside you, not something you convince others of by faking an attitude~ Rowenas Ramblings Snow Time Forums
|