RE: Our Friends, The Saudis, Will Behead A Tourist Tomorrow (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Dungeon of Political and Religious Discussion



Message


DomKen -> RE: Our Friends, The Saudis, Will Behead A Tourist Tomorrow (4/1/2010 7:26:53 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Sanity


The thing is, the Saudis are the moderates in the area. They truly are our friends, and the hope is that they will climb into the current century as the world continues to shrink because they're mingling with us through the wonders of modern travel and communication and help to lead the rest of the Middle East towards a brighter future.

The Saudis aren't moderates. Wahabism is no way shape or form moderate.

A real examination of the region shows the moderates, and our best hope for long temr friends, with the Sunni people of Jordan (actually the Hashemite monarch of Jordan has a reasonably good claim to the islamic holy cities and the parts of SA where most of the oil is. Supporting them over the House of Saud might lead to a short war and a lot of whining but might ultimately lead to a better situation), along with the Sunni and Christian populations of Lebanon.




thornhappy -> RE: Our Friends, The Saudis, Will Behead A Tourist Tomorrow (4/1/2010 7:33:17 PM)

seconds the notion about Wahabism.




Aylee -> RE: Our Friends, The Saudis, Will Behead A Tourist Tomorrow (4/1/2010 7:34:39 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: ThatDamnedPanda
Stop propping up this 15th Century tribal regime, and let their political situation sort itself out internally.


Psst. . . Panda, that "15th century tribal regime" would be the Ottoman Empire.  Personally, I would prefer NOT to see that again.  Middle Eastern destabilization is much better. 




Sanity -> RE: Our Friends, The Saudis, Will Behead A Tourist Tomorrow (4/1/2010 7:41:10 PM)


What would be your best ideas for trying to moderate the Wahhabiists in the region?




ThatDamnedPanda -> RE: Our Friends, The Saudis, Will Behead A Tourist Tomorrow (4/1/2010 7:43:29 PM)

Moderates? Jesus christ!! Only in a Tom Clancy novel. Wahhabi is the root from which bin Laden and al Qaeda grew!  These savages behead their own children for having sex before marriage. These are the  "moderates" who are going to "lead the rest of the Middle East toward a brighter future?"

Moderates. Good god. Only Sanity would consider lunatics like this to be "moderates."




Sanity -> RE: Our Friends, The Saudis, Will Behead A Tourist Tomorrow (4/1/2010 7:53:06 PM)


The Saudi monarchy is moderate and friendly towards the West, especially in comparison to such governments in the area as the Iranian regime, and to the Iraq regime under Saddam, and Syria, and Libya, and so on.

They too are battling al-Qaeda and they are at least open to discussions. I seem to recall a certain Barack Obama bowing down low before the King and so at least two out of two presidents think they're friends who are worth holding on to.


quote:

ORIGINAL: ThatDamnedPanda

Moderates? Jesus christ!! Only in a Tom Clancy novel. Wahhabi is the root from which bin Laden and al Qaeda grew!  These savages behead their own children for having sex before marriage. These are the  "moderates" who are going to "lead the rest of the Middle East toward a brighter future?"

Moderates. Good god. Only Sanity would consider lunatics like this to be "moderates."





ThatDamnedPanda -> RE: Our Friends, The Saudis, Will Behead A Tourist Tomorrow (4/1/2010 7:54:00 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Aylee

quote:

ORIGINAL: ThatDamnedPanda
Stop propping up this 15th Century tribal regime, and let their political situation sort itself out internally.


Psst. . . Panda, that "15th century tribal regime" would be the Ottoman Empire.  Personally, I would prefer NOT to see that again.  Middle Eastern destabilization is much better. 


Well, point taken about the Ottomans. I could have used a better turn of phrase.

But the point is, the royal family of Saudi Arabia wants to run their country as though they were still in the Dark Ages. The only reason they get away with it is because we support them and enable their atrocities. If it were possible to withdraw that support, their regime would collapse and they'd be hung like dogs in the street by the people they've been oppressing and mutilating for almost a century. Personally, I'd like to see that happen. It'd be bloody and it'd be chaotic, but in the long run probably far less so than the current state of affairs, and it's almost certainly inevitable at some point anyway. I'd like to see us step back and let them work it out.




Sanity -> RE: Our Friends, The Saudis, Will Behead A Tourist Tomorrow (4/1/2010 8:04:09 PM)


And after all the bloodshed, who would take charge? The people are overwhelmingly Islamic fundamentalists and so odds are good that they would end up forming into a Wahhabi or Taliban or Al-Qaeda ran theocracy which would make the current Monarchs there seem like cute cuddly little teddy bears.

Then there is always the fundamentalist Islamic need to take over the world in the name of Allah (one country at a time) so if anything resembling your madness were ever to become a reality it could easily end up sparking world war three.


quote:

ORIGINAL: ThatDamnedPanda
Well, point taken about the Ottomans. I could have used a better turn of phrase.

But the point is, the royal family of Saudi Arabia wants to run their country as though they were still in the Dark Ages. The only reason they get away with it is because we support them and enable their atrocities. If it were possible to withdraw that support, their regime would collapse and they'd be hung like dogs in the street by the people they've been oppressing and mutilating for almost a century. Personally, I'd like to see that happen. It'd be bloody and it'd be chaotic, but in the long run probably far less so than the current state of affairs, and it's almost certainly inevitable at some point anyway. I'd like to see us step back and let them work it out.





TheHeretic -> RE: Our Friends, The Saudis, Will Behead A Tourist Tomorrow (4/1/2010 8:04:29 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Aneirin

I am just wondering what will happen when the oil in those regions finally runs out,



Storage facility for spent nuclear fuel.  That's all it will be good for.  Good riddance, and the rest of the world will be kissing the ass of the US and Canada, because we have the big piles of shale oil.  [:D]




DomKen -> RE: Our Friends, The Saudis, Will Behead A Tourist Tomorrow (4/1/2010 8:10:27 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Sanity


What would be your best ideas for trying to moderate the Wahhabiists in the region?


Can't be done. Wahabism is antithetical to western values. Like I said better to dump the house of Saud for the Hashemites.




DomKen -> RE: Our Friends, The Saudis, Will Behead A Tourist Tomorrow (4/1/2010 8:13:17 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Sanity


And after all the bloodshed, who would take charge? The people are overwhelmingly Islamic fundamentalists and so odds are good that they would end up forming into a Wahhabi or Taliban or Al-Qaeda ran theocracy which would make the current Monarchs there seem like cute cuddly little teddy bears.

Then there is always the fundamentalist Islamic need to take over the world in the name of Allah (one country at a time) so if anything resembling your madness were ever to become a reality it could easily end up sparking world war three.


quote:

ORIGINAL: ThatDamnedPanda
Well, point taken about the Ottomans. I could have used a better turn of phrase.

But the point is, the royal family of Saudi Arabia wants to run their country as though they were still in the Dark Ages. The only reason they get away with it is because we support them and enable their atrocities. If it were possible to withdraw that support, their regime would collapse and they'd be hung like dogs in the street by the people they've been oppressing and mutilating for almost a century. Personally, I'd like to see that happen. It'd be bloody and it'd be chaotic, but in the long run probably far less so than the current state of affairs, and it's almost certainly inevitable at some point anyway. I'd like to see us step back and let them work it out.



Actually the people who live in SA are mostly moderate Sunni and very western looking. Get rid of the House of Saud and get a representative government in place and it could easily become a very western part of the ME.




Brain -> RE: Our Friends, The Saudis, Will Behead A Tourist Tomorrow (4/1/2010 8:15:49 PM)

They're in Israel, too:

http://stop-stoning.org/node/474


quote:

ORIGINAL: ThatDamnedPanda

quote:

(CNN) -- A Lebanese man charged with sorcery and sentenced to death in Saudi Arabia is scheduled to be beheaded on Friday, the man's lawyer said Wednesday. May El Khansa, the attorney for Ali Hussain Sibat, told CNN that she and Sibat's family were informed about the upcoming execution. She said she heard from a source in Saudi Arabia with knowledge of the case and the proceedings that Saudi authorities "will carry out the execution."

The Saudi Ministry of Justice could not immediately be reached for comment on the matter. El Khansa said she has appealed to Lebanon's prime minister, Saad Hariri, and president, Michel Suleiman, to stop the execution. Amnesty International, the human rights group, has called on Saudi Arabia's King Abdullah to block it as well.

Sibat is the former host of a popular call-in show that aired on Beirut-based satellite TV channel "Sheherazade." According to his lawyer, Sibat would predict the future on his show and give out advice to his audience. El Khansa told CNN her client was arrested by Saudi Arabia's religious police (known as the Mutawa'een) and charged with sorcery while visiting the country in May 2008. Sibat was in Saudi Arabia to perform the Islamic religious pilgrimage known as Umra.


No Refund On The Return Ticket, Either!


So. These ignorant, barbaric savages are going to behead someone who came to their country as a tourist because he tells fortunes on television in his home country. You know what? Fuck these people. Pump every drop of it out, pay them fair value, and get the hell out of the Middle East. Let them burn each other at the stake if that's what they want to do. They want to live in the 15th Century, let 'em have at it.





MrRodgers -> RE: Our Friends, The Saudis, Will Behead A Tourist Tomorrow (4/1/2010 8:21:59 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Sanity


That must be the same kind of attitude that conquistadors such as Cortez had after witnessing things like Montezuma's human sacrifices. The kind of thinking that drove the subjugation of those thought to be 'primitives' in Africa and the Americas, and so on.

You make the whole point of the OP...that was centuries ago and nobody else is still brutally stuck in the past...but the Saudis.




Sanity -> RE: Our Friends, The Saudis, Will Behead A Tourist Tomorrow (4/1/2010 8:22:43 PM)


The bottom line is, it doesn't matter who is in charge of a nation like Saudi Arabia, to the entire population such beheadings are required by an authority much higher than the King. The reason I stand by my affirmation that they're our friends is that we're in a position to exchange ideas with them.

They're human beings and they're here to stay so we might as well try to get along with them, and if we exchange ideas with them and turn them on to things like science and porn eventually they'll come around.




slvemike4u -> RE: Our Friends, The Saudis, Will Behead A Tourist Tomorrow (4/1/2010 8:23:29 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Sanity


The thing is, the Saudis are the moderates in the area. They truly are our friends, and the hope is that they will climb into the current century as the world continues to shrink because they're mingling with us through the wonders of modern travel and communication and help to lead the rest of the Middle East towards a brighter future.
Do you really believe the shit you type....or is it just that it is the party line and you feel duty bound to parrot it?
They are about to behead a man...for the crime of "fortune telling" and you refer to them as moderates( and I don't care who their neighbors are.....they are not and never have been moderates).




Silence8 -> RE: Our Friends, The Saudis, Will Behead A Tourist Tomorrow (4/1/2010 8:28:48 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: ThatDamnedPanda

Moderates? Jesus christ!! Only in a Tom Clancy novel. Wahhabi is the root from which bin Laden and al Qaeda grew!  These savages behead their own children for having sex before marriage. These are the  "moderates" who are going to "lead the rest of the Middle East toward a brighter future?"

Moderates. Good god. Only Sanity would consider lunatics like this to be "moderates."



It's almost endearing after a while.

Almost.




Kirata -> RE: Our Friends, The Saudis, Will Behead A Tourist Tomorrow (4/1/2010 8:30:40 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: MrRodgers

nobody else is still brutally stuck in the past...but the Saudis.

You have until 00:51 for a face-saving edit.

K.




Sanity -> RE: Our Friends, The Saudis, Will Behead A Tourist Tomorrow (4/1/2010 8:31:05 PM)



Some of the things we do seem just as bad to them, mike, and they could be right about some of it. But since you're sure you're without sin, go ahead and cast that first stone I suppose.


quote:

ORIGINAL: slvemike4uDo you really believe the shit you type....or is it just that it is the party line and you feel duty bound to parrot it?
They are about to behead a man...for the crime of "fortune telling" and you refer to them as moderates( and I don't care who their neighbors are.....they are not and never have been moderates).




slvemike4u -> RE: Our Friends, The Saudis, Will Behead A Tourist Tomorrow (4/1/2010 8:34:06 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Sanity


Some of the things we do seem just as bad to them, mike, and they could be right about some of it. But since you're sure you're without sin, go ahead and cast that stone I suppose.


quote:

ORIGINAL: slvemike4uDo you really believe the shit you type....or is it just that it is the party line and you feel duty bound to parrot it?
They are about to behead a man...for the crime of "fortune telling" and you refer to them as moderates( and I don't care who their neighbors are.....they are not and never have been moderates).

See,right there is what I mean...Do you actually believe one must be without sin to condemm beheading a man for this bullshit....Are you really that daft.....or is it simply a case of being so firmly wedded to your political outlook that sounding like an ass is just another part of the deal?




Sanity -> RE: Our Friends, The Saudis, Will Behead A Tourist Tomorrow (4/1/2010 8:37:18 PM)


I don't feel like I'm god-like enough to judge them "ignorant, barbaric savages" like you and your ilk. I see them as human beings who could possibly use some enlightenment, just like me. 




Page: <<   < prev  1 [2] 3 4 5   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.03125