Anaxagoras
Posts: 3086
Joined: 5/9/2009
From: Eire
Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: tweakabelle
quote:
ORIGINAL: Anaxagoras
I see Tweakabelle is doing a copy and paste job because the above post was on the now deleted Wikileaks..Israel thread. On there Politesub said he didn't agree that Israel should be remotely compared with the Nazi's. Tweakabelle agreed but has in fact compared Israel with the Nazi's in the past, e.g. stating Gaza was a reenactment of the Warsaw Ghetto.
Actually I published a post agreeing with Politesub53's criticism of comparisons of Israel to the Nazis. It may the case that you didn't see it before the thread was deleted. Whatever the case, a withdrawal would be appreciated.
You didn't read my post above properly. I said you put up where you agreed with Politesubs's assertion ("IMHO" as you put it) but the hypocricy of it is that you brought up the Warsaw Ghetto with regard to Gaza on an old thread. Its part of the little game you play when moderates on the thread express reservations about the more extreme pro-Palestinian assertions. Anerin was merely responding to your totally unnecessary bringing up of the Nazi principle of "untermensch" referring to sub-people. Its another comparison.
quote:
And your claim that I had done so in the past is also incorrect. What I actually said was the Gaza invasion of 2008 was as near a re-enactment of the Warsaw Ghetto as I ever wanted to see in my life, which is quite different.
As I said you brought up the Warsaw Ghetto with regard to Gaza on an old thread. At the time of the Gaza war many pro-Palestinians said it was the same as the Warsaw Ghetto. You said it was "as near a reenactment as I care to see" - no doubt now you will pretend that wasn't a comparison but it is obvious for all to see you did. Politesub said comparisons were not at all justified so it was indeed hypocricy to agree with him even if you didn't mean to compare 100% as there you were bringing it up and comparing.
quote:
Please stop paraphrasing my words. You invariably get the meaning wrong, whether by design or accident. If you wish to criticise what I say, please quote me. Copying and pasting is not beyond your abilities.
The meaning I asserted is entirely justified as above. I have also quoted you very extensively when you asked for justification so don't pretend that I misleadingly paraphrase.
|
RE: Is this one of the reasons why Palestinians..... - 
Profile
New Messages
No New Messages
Hot Topic w/ New Messages
Hot Topic w/o New Messages
Locked w/ New Messages
Locked w/o New Messages
Post New Thread