Collarchat.com

Join Our Community
Collarchat.com

Home  Login  Search 

Punishment to suit the crime - new Dom


View related threads: (in this forum | in all forums)

Logged in as: Guest
 
All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Ask a Master >> Punishment to suit the crime - new Dom Page: [1]
Login
Message << Older Topic   Newer Topic >>
Punishment to suit the crime - new Dom - 3/26/2004 10:39:38 AM   
DaddyTomCat


Posts: 2
Joined: 3/1/2004
Status: offline
Hello everyone.

I have a subbie with whom I play regularly. Every week or so.

We have a fantastic relationship involving good company, conversation and fantastic sex and play. The problem is this:

I do not want anything more than what it is. This was the initial agreement, to be play partners and nothing more.

Recently, she has become more emotionally involved. She once told me that she wanted more, and when I said that this was not possible from me, she backed down and said she wouild be happy as it is.

Last night however, the topic surfaced again. And the worst part of it is that whilst cooking me dinner (i didnt notice) but she was slipping into the cupboard where she had a half bottle of burboun stashed. She polshed almost the lot and then brought up the topic above.

So I was wondering if any Doms or subs out there wanted to offer me some advice about how to handel this situation. This is how I see it:

1. Break it off
2. Devise a punishment

the 3rd option, go 24/7 is not an option for me.

I dont particularly want to break it off, although I want to keep her best interests, so I will discuss that with her; but it will end up puniishment.

Any suggestions as to an adequate punishment guys?

Cheers

DaddyTomCat
Profile   Post #: 1
RE: Punishment to suit the crime - new Dom - 3/26/2004 10:51:47 AM   
seattleminx


Posts: 46
Joined: 1/1/2004
From: Seattle, WA
Status: offline
quote:

ORIGINAL: DaddyTomCat

Hello everyone.

I have a subbie with whom I play regularly. Every week or so.

We have a fantastic relationship involving good company, conversation and fantastic sex and play. The problem is this:

I do not want anything more than what it is. This was the initial agreement, to be play partners and nothing more.

Recently, she has become more emotionally involved. She once told me that she wanted more, and when I said that this was not possible from me, she backed down and said she wouild be happy as it is.

Last night however, the topic surfaced again. And the worst part of it is that whilst cooking me dinner (i didnt notice) but she was slipping into the cupboard where she had a half bottle of burboun stashed. She polshed almost the lot and then brought up the topic above.

So I was wondering if any Doms or subs out there wanted to offer me some advice about how to handel this situation. This is how I see it:

1. Break it off
2. Devise a punishment

the 3rd option, go 24/7 is not an option for me.

I dont particularly want to break it off, although I want to keep her best interests, so I will discuss that with her; but it will end up puniishment.

Any suggestions as to an adequate punishment guys?

Cheers

DaddyTomCat


Punishment may not be the best option at this point. She wants something that you are unable to give. Until she understands this to a point where it's ingrained in her behavior around you, there will always be this dissonance. The fact that she had to drink in order to muster up the courage probably tells just how much this has been on her mind.

I think it boils down to this... which will be more painful to your sub...the short term punishment surrounding their behavior, or the realization that your relationship with her will not go as far as she may desire. If your desire is to do what's best for your sub, then the answer will be clear.

Just my perspective, and not necessarily the best one out there. For me, someone can hurt my body and I'd be okay with it. But hurt my heart, and that's a wound that takes far longer to heal.

(in reply to DaddyTomCat)
Profile   Post #: 2
RE: Punishment to suit the crime - new Dom - 3/26/2004 12:14:51 PM   
EStrict


Posts: 729
Joined: 1/11/2004
Status: offline
quote:

I dont particularly want to break it off, although I want to keep her best interests, so I will discuss that with her; but it will end up puniishment.


Honestly Sir, I do not see this comment as possible. It ending up punishment so it can continue *as is* is not her best interests, it's yours. Though you may have discussed it not ending up 24/7, one thing about power exchange relationships, are they involve emotions. Emotions are tied to *needs*, and where are her *logical* and *rational* mind understood the orginal agreement, her *human* and *emotional* side have found out it needs more. IMO to punish her for that is just wrong.

You may not *want* to break it off, but if you do honestly want HER best interest and you are not willing or able to have to relationship evolve into the more she needs, it is something you really should consider.

< Message edited by EStrict -- 3/26/2004 12:16:17 PM >


_____________________________

Sandy

Don't take life too seriously, no one gets out alive anyway...

(in reply to DaddyTomCat)
Profile   Post #: 3
RE: Punishment to suit the crime - new Dom - 3/26/2004 4:09:06 PM   
Estring


Posts: 3314
Joined: 1/1/2004
Status: offline
I see it as an obvious ( though painful ) choice. You need to break it off. She will never be happy without more commitment from you, and all the punishment in the world won't change that. And as a consequence, you will become less and less satisfied if you stay with her. It was a great ride, but it is over.

(in reply to EStrict)
Profile   Post #: 4
RE: Punishment to suit the crime - new Dom - 3/26/2004 6:25:27 PM   
MizSuz


Posts: 1881
Joined: 1/1/2004
Status: offline
I'm afraid I'm going to have to be the dissenting vote...or perhaps you could call it the other view.

I do not agree that punishment is appropriate in this instance. This is not a mutual behavior goal to which you use corrective means, nor does it seem to me to be a blatant disregard for the rules (you have said that the dynamic was established but you seemed to insinuate that the agreed upon dynamic did not encompass behavior modification to address this issue). The issue at hand is personal responsibility.

Being a deliriously happy single dominant woman I am well acquainted with being involved with people who want more than I am willing to give. If I ended every relationship when the other person wanted more than I was willing to give I'd have a trail of casualties behind me.

I am forthright, honest (perhaps to a fault) and I pull no punches regarding these sorts of things. No subterfuge, no attempts to smooth things over. Just the facts. I am also willing to listen to them discuss their wants, desires, etc. As long as they are able to deal with my facts, they are entitled to WANT anything. The bottom line is I am not the one who will give it to them and if it's important enough to them to have then THEY should choose to leave or allow our relationship to become something else (likely less than what they want). If, in the process of their expressing their wants it starts to sound like whining, bitching, pissing and moaning, manipulation or anything of the like...I make it very clear with them that I am not enjoying the interaction and if it continues I will stop interacting. Then...I do what I say. If they would like to not attempt to engage me in something I don't wish to partake in then they are welcome to return....otherwise...move on. Otherwise, listening to someone wax poetic about an LTR or such with me is tantamount to listening to a friend fantasize about hitting the lottery (or anything else your friends may fantasize about). I feel no obligation to fill that desire for them. I've been quite clear that I won't. Think of it as MY hard limit. We tops are entitled to them too, ya know.

You'd be AMAZED at how many people seem to thrive under that sort of relationship. Those that can't deal with it should move on...but it will be their choice to do so unless I simply don't enjoy their company anymore.

But then I rarely punish and when I do it's harshly memorable and never ever wanted again. There is play, there is correction and there is punishment. Correction is done to facilitate a process, punishment is meted out for blatant disregard for rules. If I am punishing you I'm thinking "why bother?"

Why would you want to tell someone you care about that their hopes, dreams and desires are not something you want to hear, unless you had some issues with not being able/willing to provide them. Take away any feelings you may have about that and would you listen anyway?

Is this her issue, or yours?

_____________________________

“The more you love, the more you can love—and the more intensely you love. Nor is there any limit on how many you can love. If a person had time enough, he could love all of that majority who are decent and just.”
- Robert Heinlein

(in reply to DaddyTomCat)
Profile   Post #: 5
RE: Punishment to suit the crime - new Dom - 3/26/2004 6:37:06 PM   
inyouagain


Posts: 418
Joined: 1/6/2004
Status: offline
A few questions:

Did the once before discussion include the topic of punishment for future intolerances?
What has been your position all along regarding her drinking without your permission?
Have there been any instances/punishments regarding drinking without your permission?

The description makes it sound as if in sober thought she was handling it, but I don't know the length of time between once before and the present.

I could see punishing her for drinking without permission, but her behavior after drinking should be expected to be different from sober.

Is it possible the covertly consumed half bottle of bourbon is the real problem, while your sub may have been ok with your once before discussion?

Punish her for the covert drinking without permission... don't consider punishing her for her emotions, especially when external 'judgement affecting' (half bottle of bourbon) stimulus is present. Emotions can be triggered by even the slightest of stimuli.

Emphasis concerning determining a need for, or type of punishment should only be for intolerables committed in the sub's unimpaired judgement... her first covert sip.

If booze is a problem, deal with that first. Once (and if) you get on down the road from the covert drinking incident... you may find success as you wished, or you may find the fun ride is indeed over.

Inyouagain

(in reply to DaddyTomCat)
Profile   Post #: 6
RE: Punishment to suit the crime - new Dom - 3/28/2004 2:02:33 AM   
DaddyTomCat


Posts: 2
Joined: 3/1/2004
Status: offline
This is probably the best answer i have heard, closed to my line of thinking, and I thnk you very much.

I do not fully understand the last point you where making.

IS this my problem or hers? To me clearly it is hers. I dont mind listening to her concerns, but I (we) have drawn the ground rules long ago. I care about her, yes. She is entitled to leave at any point in time.

I think it is her problem not mine? Can you explain exactly what you meant please

thanks again

(in reply to MizSuz)
Profile   Post #: 7
RE: Punishment to suit the crime - new Dom - 3/28/2004 5:52:30 AM   
MizSuz


Posts: 1881
Joined: 1/1/2004
Status: offline
quote:

ORIGINAL: DaddyTomCat

I think it is her problem not mine? Can you explain exactly what you meant please

thanks again



I'd be happy to. <smile>

How do you feel when she discusses "more"? The answer may very well be right there (assuming it's your problem...and I'm not sure it is).

It's easy to feel a plethora of things if you are with someone who is communicating to you that what you are giving isn't enough. It doesn't matter if you're dominant or submissive. I got the impression that perhaps you are having some sort of inner struggle over it (and am quite willing to acknowledge that I could be wrong). The 'release her or punish her' alternatives seemed to indicate to me that you are a bit at your wits end or something similar. Are you?

If you have any sort of inner conflict about the situation then I suggest that there may be something for you to learn about yourself in this situation. Examples could be feelings of inadequacy, powerlessness, frustration, being cornered, etc.

I'll give you an example. I have been friends for about three years with someone who wants nothing in the world more than me to marry him and move across country to be with him. He's reached a point where he understands that I will never marry him, so now he just shoots for getting me to move to be closer. I always decline and in the last year or so have stopped even responding in most instances. In the beginning he spent a lot of time trying to make me feel responsible for his unhappiness because I am not giving him what he wants. Were I someone with even a bit of codependency it would have been very easy for me to feel like a horrible person because I am not giving someone I genuinely care about what they profess they need to be happy. I've had too much therapy to be codependent in this regard. I'm quite clear that his unhappiness is founded in his refusal to accept my position as final. I'm of the opinion that he enjoys (or at least is addicted to the drama of) pining after someone he can't have. I do not feel the need to punish him for his desires, nor do I feel the need to do 'something' to deal with his painful feelings or to 'adjust' his feelings. They are his and he is welcome to them (even though they make him miserable). When interacting with him is not pleasant to me then I withdraw and refuse to participate, otherwise we enjoy each other's company and spend a good bit of time together (r/t and online).

If I was not able to clearly see that his misery is his own making, and realize that the best I can do is be forthright about my feelings and position, I might be motivated to try to 'fix it' for him...perhaps by either 'releasing him' (although I do not formally own him I could simply refuse to interact with him - thereby 'releasing' him from our current relationship) or by 'punishing him' when he communicates his desires, or by trying to 'train' him to think and feel another way. Since his feelings are of his own making and I have been very clear about my position, I feel no need to change the situation for him. He must find his own balance in it. It's not for me to find for him. He would tell you that since he's been held accountable for his own feelings in this way he has learned a great deal about himself that he may not have learned otherwise.

How do you feel about your submissive's want for more of you? Do you find yourself wanting to 'fix' her feelings or change them? If so, why? Do you feel responsible for her 'misery' because you can't give her what she wants? Do you feel pushed or manipulated? The notion that you need to take corrective action regarding the way she is feeling suggests you may have some of these feelings or something similar. If so, then I think the best course of action for you is to deal with YOUR feelings first so that YOUR feelings are not part of the dynamic you employ with her over this issue.

Have you discussed with her why she returns to a place where you have agreed not to go? Do you know whether or not she holds you responsible for these feelings she's experiencing or whether she is content to just feel the way she does while accepting that you do not feel this way or want these things? Why do you think that 'punishment' is an appropriate response to this situation? Do you realize that relationships are a living thing and therefore will change; and that periodic revisiting of rules, dynamics and goals is appropriate (as opposed to punishing for what seems obvious to me is the need to revisit the boundaries and definitions)?

When I suggested that it may be your problem I was suggesting that perhaps you have some feelings that you could learn from in this situation. It's quite possible, or even probable, that there is something to be learned for both of you in this situation. Do you realize that the only REAL power you have is over yourself? The power you have over her is the power she GIVES you and the bottom line is that it's not really YOUR power...it's hers. She has the power to make herself feel better in this instance, you do not. In this situation you have the power to change your own feelings, the power to change your own behavior, and the power to create a safe place for the both of you to explore this situation. You do not have the power to change her feelings...she must do that for herself.

You'll note that I have never addressed the drinking. I make no assumptions about her use of alcohol nor about her 'sneaking' to drink because I don't have enough information about it. Whether or not that is at issue (and is a contributing factor to the problem) is between the two of you to decide. It doesn't change anything regarding the above.

So, in the tiresome and repetitive way that therapists have I say to you "and just how do you feel about this?"

< Message edited by MizSuz -- 3/28/2004 9:01:49 AM >


_____________________________

“The more you love, the more you can love—and the more intensely you love. Nor is there any limit on how many you can love. If a person had time enough, he could love all of that majority who are decent and just.”
- Robert Heinlein

(in reply to DaddyTomCat)
Profile   Post #: 8
RE: Punishment to suit the crime - new Dom - 4/5/2004 6:05:25 PM   
confusetheswede


Posts: 48
Joined: 4/5/2004
From: THE DIRTY DIRTY
Status: offline
break it off.

(in reply to DaddyTomCat)
Profile   Post #: 9
RE: Punishment to suit the crime - new Dom - 4/6/2004 8:01:58 PM   
ZenMaster


Posts: 52
Joined: 1/30/2004
Status: offline
Sounds like she has issues and not ready for any type of relationship right now, let alone a BDSM one. Break it off is my advice but also be there as a friend to help her deal with her issues if she'll accept that. If not, simply let go.

Take care and good luck.

ZM

(in reply to DaddyTomCat)
Profile   Post #: 10
RE: Punishment to suit the crime - new Dom - 4/9/2004 4:25:08 AM   
TalN


Posts: 10
Joined: 4/7/2004
Status: offline
My recommendation would depend on your existing rules, but I would address the alchohol issue first. Ban it entirely for her when with you until she can prove she has earned it. Not just when playing - anytime you are present.

As for her pushing for more, its clear her needs have changed. But if you cannot meet them, someone else will have to. That can either mean she needs to find a new Master, or you need to find a surrogate for when you are not available. Otherwise her attempts to sublimate this need is going to continue to break through to the surface.

Mme. TalN

(in reply to DaddyTomCat)
Profile   Post #: 11
RE: Punishment to suit the crime - new Dom - 4/26/2004 6:59:58 PM   
Sinergy


Posts: 9383
Joined: 4/26/2004
Status: offline
Greetings,

quote:

Last night however, the topic surfaced again. And the worst part of it is that whilst cooking me dinner (i didnt notice) but she was slipping into the cupboard where she had a half bottle of burboun stashed. She polshed almost the lot and then brought up the topic above.


Hiding alcohol, bringing up important emotional topics she feels deeply about while inebriated?

Looks like substance abuse / codependancy to me.

Sinergy

(in reply to TalN)
Profile   Post #: 12
Page:   [1]
All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Ask a Master >> Punishment to suit the crime - new Dom Page: [1]
Jump to:





New Messages No New Messages
Hot Topic w/ New Messages Hot Topic w/o New Messages
Locked w/ New Messages Locked w/o New Messages
 Post New Thread
 Reply to Message
 Post New Poll
 Submit Vote
 Delete My Own Post
 Delete My Own Thread
 Rate Posts




Collarchat.com © 2024
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy

6.434