The Role of Emotion in Political Affiliation (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Dungeon of Political and Religious Discussion



Message


Aneirin -> The Role of Emotion in Political Affiliation (6/21/2011 7:04:24 AM)

As a personal interest, I began to wonder what if any bearing does emotion have on one's political affiliations, and that because many of my lot, the artistic community tend to follow liberal or socialist values or just have no interest in political affiliations at all, wheras some I know who are engaged in science or business orientated occupations follow a more conservative code and tend to believe what they are told by authority.

Now artists of whatever form are generally known for the use of emotions in their work, emotion is an important factor, wheras with others perhaps non artistic minds fact holds more prominance, perhaps the minds at work are logic versus intuition, and in political terms, idealism versus fact based actions, which holds more value and that goes onto the right brain/left brain thinking theory and how it serves humanity.

But how it serves, is anyone aware that those who tend to fail at school, drop out and pursue perhaps unlawful existances tend also to be natural artists of some kind, there indicating that the school system has failed these individuals, and that because teaching in biased towards left brain thinking, those that automaticly left brain think through birth do well, those that don't struggle as the concepts are alien to their way of thinking and that I believe  is because society believes it can mould people into being useful to society, not tailoring tuition to how people naturally think. But that is a subject for a later interest, but it aided me to come to the following question

What role does emotion have in political afiliation I wonder, well, here is an interesting essay by Jonathan Haidt, Associate Professor of Psychology ay Virinia University ;

But first a word of warning, whatever your political affiliation, if you wish to read and perhaps understand more, please leave your political affiliations at the door and approach the subject with an open mind, as the very title of the essay can and will  raise the bile in some before the even the first word of the essay is read, despite any thoughts on an open mind.

What Makes People Vote Republican by Jonathan Haidt

Note, I do not wish for this thread to devolve into the usual tit for tat political affiliation slanging match that this forum is so infamous for, as that serves no one, as I wish to view intellectual discussion on the value of emotion in political affiliation, is it a controlling factor or is it not, and furthermore as a side interest, does the left brain/right brain thinking theory also come into it ?




SilverMark -> RE: The Role of Emotion in Political Affiliation (6/21/2011 8:59:26 AM)

Iwas raised in a Kenneday Democrat household, lead by an Attorney and an Educator. Although we were well to do,(I never knew that until much later) my education in politics was started early in life. My father had a huge library made up mostly of history, and political science subjects and I read at an early age. By the time I was 10 or so, I knew where I stood on a lot of issues, based on dinner time discussions, reading, and the newspapers I was surrounded by.
My emotional make up is even much more liberal than my political leanings, I don't like what I see as political injustice, I believe we are our brother's keeper, and that as you gain you should also share. As I have aged most of my giving is now monetary, but when I was younger I was much more inclined to volunteer my time(Hell, I had no money, and time I had).
So, some nature, mostly nuture, I am a business man by trade yet, a left leaning centrist in my views. The highest compliment I was ever paid was by an exec I was working with who had become my friend, he said"Mark, you look so much like a Republican, and act so much like a Democrat"....I have since given up the suits and ties...thank God!




tazzygirl -> RE: The Role of Emotion in Political Affiliation (6/21/2011 9:07:28 AM)

Why is this posted in two different sections?




Aneirin -> RE: The Role of Emotion in Political Affiliation (6/21/2011 9:29:12 AM)

Because I fucked up, but in that other forum, you will notice if you care to look that I have given my apologies for my error.

In time I expect the moderators will come by and see what I have left and clean it up, as I have no clue how to remove the post myself.




Termyn8or -> RE: The Role of Emotion in Political Affiliation (6/21/2011 9:57:35 AM)

Consider this gross oversimplicaftion :

The poor will vote to tax the rich. The rich will vote to tax the poor.

People do what they think is best for themselves whether their perception of that is accurate or not. Everyone wants the world run their way.

Now, in the US I think more people are realizing that no politician will, or maybe even can truly represent the People, which would explain the low voter turnout.

T^T




FirmhandKY -> RE: The Role of Emotion in Political Affiliation (6/21/2011 3:27:49 PM)

I've read and posted about Haidt before.

He's pretty much right on, although he is still coming from a "liberal" point of view at times.

What I really like about him is that he is able to overcome his emotions and use intellect to analyze things, and is mature enough to step outside his own worldview and understand that just because someone disagrees with his own personal political stance that that doesn't mean that they are sub-human, morally corrupt, or just plain evil.

A lesson some of my lefty friends here on CM would benefit from learning, methinks.

Firm




Aneirin -> RE: The Role of Emotion in Political Affiliation (6/21/2011 4:32:09 PM)

I agree, I found this essay fom Haidt to be very palatable and not because of his political affiliation, because my stance is variable on that matter, meaning I am open to the truth whenever it appears, for I seek reality not promises and lies, I have had enough of them from past administrations. But Haidt to me seemed to have a genuine questioning humility as if he really desired to understand people and why they exercise their only say in the scheme of things in such ways.Believe me I have read countless crap about the advantaged and the disadvantaged and why it is assumed they vote as they do, and assumed because in the privacy of the voting cubicle, we know not what the truth of a person's vote may be. Where a person is in the tiers of society, might be an indication to how a person may vote, but as an indication that is by no means an absolute.






Page: [1]

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2024
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
1.806641E-02