RottenJohnny -> RE: Leader of Zetas drug cartel is captured (7/17/2013 5:20:57 PM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: tweakabelle There are a number of alternatives available ranging from removing all restrictions and sanctions on drug use to various models of decriminalisation and levels of regulation. Posing two extremes - blanket prohibition or doing nothing - is a false dichotomy, as well as being hopelessly simplistic. I'm glad to see you say this, tweak, because from your first post I got the impression you thought we should go ahead and give the green light to everything without consideration. To me, that was a hopelessly simplistic answer. And believe it or not, in the case of marijuana, I tend to agree with you...with some limitations. However, when you start talking about stronger drugs like cocaine and heroin, given my experience with the drug culture, legalization is a frightening and dangerous idea. quote:
What is abundantly clear is that the current policy of blanket prohibition has failed, and failed miserably, totally and irredeemably. It is clear that the current approach has failed everywhere it has been tried. Nor will increasing penalties work - the death penalties that are in place in a number of countries haven't succeeded in stopping the drug trade, rather these countries tend to have more severe drug problems than those countries that have adopted more realistic or nuanced policies. While I'll accept your use of the word "blanket", the idea that any prohibition hasn't worked simply isn't true. Back in the 80's when drug gangs were slaying each other over cocaine, current policies eventually removed the vast majority of cocaine supplies from the area where I lived. Many of my friends who were already addicted to cocaine and crack found themselves without the ability to obtain it. As a result, most eventually dried out and got on with life. If they had been able to continue getting the drugs they wanted, fewer of them would have eventually done so. quote:
Whatever alternative model is adopted, it is critical that drug use needs to be seen as a health issue, not a legal or moral one. While I agree with your statement, this brings me to another point that I'll ask you to consider. Whether you are willing to agree or not, legalization of some hard drugs is, without doubt, going to create some addicts simply because of the ease of obtaining the drugs. I'm not intending to point my finger directly at you but for those who support both national healthcare and the legalization of drugs it might be a good idea to take a moment to consider that they are supporting the right for someone to risk becoming an addict while demanding that taxpayers risk becoming responsible for paying for their treatment. I think most taxpayers will find that unacceptable.
|
|
|
|