PeonForHer -> RE: Mad Dogs and Englishmen (12/3/2014 2:50:55 PM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: freedomdwarf1 quote:
Then explain to me, why another site states that immigrants take out $119m more than they put in?? I cited that in another post. You'll have to find that post, FD. But even if it's true, $119 in national terms is pretty small beer. I do remember our talking about that, though - see comments below. Found something... Not my original cite but something similar - The IPPR analysis suggests that real revenues from migrants grew by 22% from fiscal year 1999-2000 to fiscal year 2003-2004 (reaching GBP 41.2 billion). However, the expenditure associated with immigrants reached GBP 41.6 billion in the fiscal year 2003-2004. Therefore, the net contribution of immigrants in the fiscal year 2003-2004 was negative at GBP -0.4 billion Source: http://migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/briefings/fiscal-impact-immigration-uk It's not how many, but what impact they have overall. In this study, a £0.4bn deficit to the system. My understanding is that the earlier generations of immigrants is now of retirement age. Obviously, now, they'll therefore be taking money out rather than putting it in. I've come to realise that we always have to be careful with the figures - especially the government figures - of the cost of welfare: when the government wants to make a case for 'idle non-workers', it'll included the pensions bill, the better to inflate the figure. But the Tories won't ever bash the pensioners because these tend a) to vote - versus young people and b) vote Tory, because they tend to be more right wing, stuffed up, stupid and selfish. However, younger immigrants are anything but workshy. Of course they're frigging not - why would they be? They've come from places where they've had to work a *lot* harder for a *lot* less money. For the average Eastern European, and still more for the average immigrant from the Indian subcontinent, the UK must look like a holiday camp. You do a mere, lazy forty hour week, and earn what you could only get in a quarter-year where they come from. At the same time you've been born and brought up in a society where there's no culture of benefits: you're aware, from the year dot, that you earn your money, or you die. It makes fuck all sense to bang on about 'benefit-chasing immigrants' FD. It's bollocks.
|
|
|
|