hizgeorgiapeach -> RE: Immigration law: something's got to give. (6/4/2008 6:33:57 AM)
|
If he had been born here, there would be a birth certificate on file and therefore this would be a non-issue, as HE would not be facing deportation and his mother would likely be granted some sort of extention/exception if she had no one that he could stay with until reaching his majority. (That of course assumes that he hasn't already reached his majority - legal adulthood - of 18.) For that matter, if he had been born here and that were an issue, it's become both easy and relatively common practice for 16 and 17 year olds to go to court to be granted legal emancipation from their parents prior to attaining their majority, so that they are no longer considered a ward of their parents but neither do they become a ward of the state or some other guardian until that point. It (the potential he was born here) is therefore an invalid arguement. As the article says nothing concerning his language skills, and none of us know him personally, I don't know what language (or languages) he is fluent in any more than kitten actually does, regardless of what sort of pretty assumptions are going to be made. They haven't been waiting "all these years for an answer." They were turned down on their final Appeal - which means they've been given the same answer repeatedly over the course of several attempts/years. Why weren't they deported sooner? Because they were given a legal Privilage of appealing the decision a certain number of times - hence why this was their Final appeal. The conditions which caused the mother to flee and request assylum are no longer extant - the political entity she fled from, the Soviet Union - no longer exists. Therefore the conditions under which she requested assylum are no longer valid TO be granted. There is no time when it is appropriate to "bend the rules." If you're going to start "bending" them here and there, you may as well do away with them altogether, because they become meaningless. If you "bend" for one for whatever "good" reason - you obligate yourself to "bend" for all who profess to have a "good" reason - because what YOU consider a "good" reason is not going to seem sufficient to everyone else, and vise versa. Is my answer potentially heartless? Yes - but it's also based on Reality, and reality isn't always rose colored romance, sugar and spice and everything nice, a pat on the head, and everybody getting everything they want. Reality isn't necessarily Fair, but too bad. Whine about reality not being fair in one hand, shit in the other, see which one has something substantial in it.
|
|
|
|