lonelyblueboi
Posts: 51
Joined: 12/2/2005 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: RapierFugue quote:
ORIGINAL: Aylee And I tell you again (this would be the third time, unfortunately you are not a computer that works with "I tell you three times") you have put your own definition on the phrase. It means non-infectious. Not un-clean. Not morally repugnant. You are feeling offense where there is none. I was somewhat boggled by this objection to the word "Clean", so I bunged a few phrases including and surrounding it into google. It would appear that this is something that's sprung up in the last few years, and even forms part of the FAQ/Posting guidelines on some sexual health/GUM/STI/STD forums, in terms of "please don't refer to people with X as "clean"" ... It seems to have snuck in under my radar, so "STD/STI-free" yes, "non-infectious" ok, but "clean", no. Apparently. Initially I thought "well that's a bit bloody cheeky! It's only a word, and I'll use any word I bloody well like!", but then I had a bit of a think ... Granted, I think those objecting to its use have about as much chance of stopping society at large using the term as I have of becoming the next Pope (and I'm not even Catholic), but it does seem to be out there at the moment, as an objection, so (having thought it through carefully) I'll not be using the term anymore, on the grounds that its use doesn't really hamper my ability to describe individuals as "HIV+" (or "Herpes sufferers", or "STD+" or whatever), whereas my using it might offend someone who probably has enough on their plate to start with. Now of course someone(s) can pop up with something along the lines of "score one for the thought police", but (again, having thought it through) my feelings are a) it's not a very good word to describe the state of being "HIV/STD-free" anyway, since it's perfectly possible to be HIV/STD-free and unwashed and b) it's not much effort to use another term other than "clean", in order to spare people stigma and offense. The term "clean bill of health" strikes me BTW as fine, if used in its entirety, as it's a historical term that has a very specific meaning, just not the shorthand "clean" to mean HIV-neg/STD-neg. So there we have it; that rarest of occasions - me changing my mind in the space of 24 hours Thank you RapierFugue for your sensitivity and understanding. And by the way, it is possible for a doctor to give someone a "clean bill of health" even if they do have HIV. The doctor will simply be stating that they are in general, healthy. For participating in work, school, physical activity, or whatever. Again, I appreciate those here who are willing to see how much hurt can be caused just by using certain words! lbb
|