MarcEsadrian
Posts: 852
Joined: 8/24/2008 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: ChatteParfaitt I said this: Master/slave implies one person having complete power, authority, control over, and responsibility for, another. Yes, yet there is a fairly common school of thought recognizing the mortal limits of M/s, and I count myself among them. Despite its literal connotation, the "total" in TPE has since also been disclaimed as an "ideal", to be worked towards but which will not be achieved, which is why TPE may be better seen as a process or goal than as a state. (Davidson, 1997) With that in mind, there seems to be little difference in ideals between both, in reality. Therefore, what was mysterious to me was how you found M/s to be an unrealistic fantasy and TPE to be something of a circular exchange in which the parties are "very spiritually attuned", and often "seen in old, married couples". I have no doubt growing old together in spiritual attunement can happen in TPE, but these qualities, among others, like "synergy" are not by any means excluded in M/s. quote:
ORIGINAL: ChatteParfaitt If you prefer to call your dynamic Master/slave, by all means have at it. Many do. However, you do run the risk of misleading those [who] will rush to make assumptions about your dynamic that may be false. It's true that the concept of M/s is often interpreted liberally; I don't think that's under debate. While not impervious to different interpretations, I do find M/s to have less literal ambiguity as it describes orientations/nouns, not absolute quantifications of power on its face, which tends to make the term problematic. quote:
ORIGINAL: ChatteParfaitt The term TPE allows for a similar mindset without the need to be forced into semantic fits all peg holes. Though that might be the goal, the phrase seems to encounter the same sort of misinterpretation you note happens with M/s. Considering its actual definition, however, and one I'm inclined to trust reading Jacobs / Davidson, I feel it is, as you now say, a very "similar mindset" or goal—clearly similar enough, in my mind, as to be interchangeable. quote:
ORIGINAL: ChatteParfaitt Lastly, leave my cute lil ass, smart as it is, out of the discussion, or I shall have to tell my non-Master you were flirting with me. By all means, allow me to disabuse you of that idea.
< Message edited by MarcEsadrian -- 5/4/2011 7:01:22 PM >
_____________________________
Omnes una manet nox Founder, Humbled Females
|