Padriag -> RE: Speech (5/12/2006 11:53:07 AM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: RiotGirl Padriag, He did tell her excatly what he wanted His slave to do. He gave her 4 guidlines to go by - written down even, so she can go back and double check. But - As was already said, this one likes to do her best. Sometimes that means going beyond what was told. Investigating a matter completely. Of course, all she needs to do is follow those 4 rules. Yet some how one doesnt think that Master would be upset if she did more. He might even be proud. I should hope he would be proud of you for trying your best! But I think you misunderstood the point of my post, so let's recap a bit. First, based on your original post I didn't know how clear his instructions were, but since you were asking others for advice it seemed to me that they weren't clear enough. I suggested some ideas that might help him based on things I know help me. Now, let's look at your rules. quote:
His Rules = ) RULE 1. A slave should never capitalize any reference to herself, even though there may be an instance where a sentence is started with a small letter. Appropriate reconstruction of sentences can avoid that situation. EXAMPLES: i, me, mine, hers, her, our, her first name. RULE 2. A slave should always fully capitalize the first letter of any word that refers to her Dominant person, the person with whom she is in a relationship. EXAMPLES: Sir, Master, He, His, Top, Him, You, Yours. RULE 3. A slave should always capitalize the first letter of any word that refers to her Dominant person and the slave jointly. EXAMPLES: Us, Our, We. RULE 4. A slave should whenever possible, refer to herself in the third person. EXAMPLES: Your slave, this slave, slave name RULE 5. A slave should always open and close a letter to her Master with an appropriate title or reference to his position over her. EXAMPLES: Master, Sir, my One, Lord, Your, Yours. Okay, just to clarify some terms. All of these rules fall under what I term "speech restrictions". Only Rule 4 actually deals with speaking in third person, the rest are protocols regarding forms of address and protocols for written communication. Side note: Just to be clear I'm not knocking any of it. I don't use all of these rules myself, but I do use speach restrictions and I am a big fan of protocols. I believe well defined protocols can be a helpful tool in teaching behavior and getting the desired results. End side note Looking specifically at Rule 4, this is too general in my opinion. To me it doesn't seem clear in that it gives very minimal examples of usage, nor does it address possible exceptions or cases that might be confusing. Both Bladeswing and Delight did a good job of giving the kind of written examples and rules I suggested in my first post. Thus, what I was suggesting is that your master take some time to consider how he wants you to speak, write out some examples (say a paragraph of fictional conversation that uses statements, questions and responses to give you a good general idea of what he has i mind) and some additional rules clarifying usage. It might be helpful for you and he to sit down one evening and practice this. That is, do some practice conversations, role play some situations, during which he corrects your speech as you practice. That can work if he isn't entirely sure what he wants himself, gives you both a chance to "work through it" together. I think its great you're trying your best, that's exactly what you should be doing. I'm not condemning, just offering what helpful advice I can. Your original question is really almost impossible to answer because ultimately the only rules that matter are the ones he makes, and no one on here has any way to know what that might be. Hence the suggestions on things you and your master might do to work it out. While I could give you my rules on 3rd person, what I might want might be at odds with what he wants; and if so, it could actually get you in trouble. I wouldn't want that.
|
|
|
|