DeviantlyD
Posts: 4375
Joined: 5/26/2007 From: Hawai`i Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: mummyman321 quote:
ORIGINAL: DeviantlyD No malice, but clearly condescension. As for your last sentence, perhaps you missed reading the bit in my post, which I've highlighted to match how I've highlighted your statement. What I have a problem with is a person who does not have medical knowledge of something, which you admittedly do not, saying something is not safe when you have not used it and you do not know how it works. You misrepresented the medical facts. I simply presented the correct medical facts. I am not being mean about it. I think that has be an interesting discussion as it allows other to learn, gain knowledge and make their own judgements. I have always been a fan of talk to your doctor or other medical expert. And if you talk to them, they will tell you using a Condom catheter is perfectly safe to do so (within the context of being a healthly male). quote:
ORIGINAL: DeviantlyD Any urine going into the bag is going to pick up some of the skin flora. The bag, placed against the leg, will provide a warm temperature to help any bacteria in the bag to grow in number. That's the bacteria factory I'm talking about, not the skin of the penis. Again, your data here is not entirely correct. Urine is sterile in the human body unless you have an infection already. Thinks like bladder infections are due to bacterial growing and multiplying in the mucas lining of the bladder, urethra or other body tissue. The bacteria generally does not grow in multiply in the urine alone. Actually that never happens inside the body ever. The tip of the penis, specifically the exit of the urethra is always wet with urine. And this urine does come into contact with the outer skin of the penis in microscopic form. So why don't men constantly develop urine tract infections since that skin is so full of harmful bacteria as you put it? The answer is 1) Most bacteria on the skin is not harmful 2) The action of urination constantly flushes the area with a sterile fluid and does not allow any bacteria that may be present to multiply. Can bacterial grow inside the urine collection bag? The answer is yes. Is it harmful bacteria? Generally no. The real question is how long does it take to bacterial to grow to a harmful mass. Well since most leg bags hold less than a liter, after 1 or 2 urinations it will need to be emptied. So there simply not be enough time for a harmful colony to develop. Hence that is why millions of people use them everyday with no problems. quote:
ORIGINAL: DeviantlyD As for the polluted river, lake, etc.? It's certainly possible to get an infection if certain organisms are present. Ever hear of swimmer's ear? Not to mention the possibility of gaining other types of bacterial and parasitic infections. If there are any opportunistic organisms present in that body of water, it could come in contact with a mucosal surface, gain entry and produce a subsequent infection. This is not to say it will happen absolutely, but the possibility is distinct and present. Again here you present medical data with no facts. Swimmer's Ear is a generic term for inflammation of the ear canal. This can be caused by bacteria or fungus. The bacteria or fungus is generally present in the water and not from the bacterial on your skin in your ear. The most common cause of swimmer's ear is due to bacteria or the fungus coming in contact with the mucus lining in the ear canal. Usually this occurs due to a break or tear in the skin. People who use Q tips to clean their ears suffer a much higher rate of swimmer's ear than those who do not use that type of product. The action of cleaning the ear with the swab causes microscopbic breaks in the skin allowing the bacteria or fungus to enter. That is why people who use Q tips to clean their ear, percentage wise, more often develop swimmer's ear. It's hopeless trying to get my point across. I never said bacteria was in the urine coming from the body. I'm well aware of how any body fluid within the body is sterile until it leaves it, if it does leave at all. Obviously urine leaves the body, other fluids don't, under normal circumstances. I clearly stated "any urine going into the bag is going to pick up some of the skin flora". "Skin flora" equates to bacteria on the skin that normally resides there. I guess you aren't familiar with the phrase. As for the bag emptying? Well let's just say, where did you mention this in your earlier post? I envisioned a bag of urine collecting for 24 hours or more, and no matter what you believe, the skin bacteria would grown in urine that was stagnant for that long a period of time. And where did I say that it was harmful? I didn't. I would think it's possible to be harmful, yes, but I never said anything beyond it being a bacteria factory. Swimmer's ear can be defined as an inflammation of the ear canal, but it's also described as an infection. And I was responding to your comment that a person swimming in polluted water wouldn't get an infection, which is possible, but it's also very possible that they could get an infection. Once again, you are reading words into my statements. I only responded to that statement, independent of your comments presented in the OP. I'm done with this thread. It's pointless trying to explain my simple statement to you, when you read so much into my comments with statements I've never made and when you make such strong assumptions about what my knowledge base is, irrespective of the subject matter.
|