LadyEllen -> RE: Heritage or Hate? (9/18/2007 8:50:31 AM)
|
Good point MC, but not the point I believe. There is a world of difference between making a critique or writing an allegorical story, and deliberately setting out to offend. I wholeheartedly support freedom of speech and expression - but there is a limit to it. Rushdie's book was OK, but if he'd written a placard reading "Mohammed is a pig" and stood outside the Mosque with it on Friday, it wouldnt be OK. I guess if I'm to be pushed on where this not so subtle line lies, it is with true vs false. For example - "black boys do poorly in the education system after age 12" is OK. Anyone getting offended by that fact, which can be backed up by evidence, is off their trolley. Its not offensive - its a call to do something about it. however "black boys are morons" is not OK. It does not reflect fact (in fact it seems that black boys lose interest in education, not intellectual capacity) and implies a negative value judgement on a group. Those who set out to offend tend to steer clear of facts, rely on stereotypes and use negative value judgements in this way. E
|
|
|
|