hausboy -> RE: desperate and depressed (11/12/2011 12:18:41 PM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: LafayetteLady quote:
ORIGINAL: hausboy I've been working on becoming a minimalist as part of my own spiritual path for the past year or so (from being a pack rat, no less!) and these days, it's all about the experience as the gift and not a material "thing". I no longer need or want gifts (in the traditional sense).... I've asked my brother's wife (who is obsessed with material gift giving) to please stop buying me gifts for the holiday. I've given her a list of my favorite charities....which she ignores....and I've even tried asking for consumables (cookies, homemade...no tin or packaging)...and that was ignored too. I was told I was being selfish because I was depriving her of HER experience of shopping, which she enjoys. My ex-wife and her family were also obsessed with gifts....rarely practical or useful...and over the past year, I've sold or donated virtually everything they ever gave me. Time IS the gift. spending time with those you love, doing things you enjoy, is far more precious a commodity than anything you could ever purchase or create. I wouldn't use the term "selfish" but in a sense, if that is what she enjoys (and many people do), you are depriving her of a part of what she enjoys for the holiday. You can only express your desires to others in terms of gift receiving/giving. After that, the best thing you can do is smile, say thank you and appreciate, that as misguided the gift may be, the giver put thoughts of you into buying. Then sell or donate as you have been. I can hear that....but.... then again.... what is the part that she truly enjoys? the act of shopping? is it the act of giving the gift or the satisfaction of giving when you put thought into it? I'm always gracious...even though one year I was given a 44" belt (I wear a 30")...which makes me wonder exactly HOW much thought is going into it? Look, I like giving gifts because I love to see the person's reaction, and know that they can use what I've given them (I'm a Taurus...practicality is a "thing" you know?) But if someone says to me "instead of gifts, would you consider donating to my favorite charity this year, I'm more than happy. I love barelynangel's idea--maybe I just need to ask her to shop for someone else on my behalf... I just thought that when you give a gift, it's to make the recipient happy, and the joy you get from giving is just a nice added bonus. there is one caveat: one year, I asked my ex what she wanted for her birthday and she said "oh nothing! there's really nothing I want...just your love..." Can't believe I fell for that. Boy, was she pissed. I learned the hard way that "nothing" was code for "I want a romantic dinner, jewelry, flowers, mushy card and a big party."
|
|
|
|