AislynLass
Posts: 56
Joined: 7/5/2009 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: NihilusZero ...but only one of us is proposing a system that tells or mandates other people to act a certain way, even if their actions are consensual. This is the point that seems to be getting lost in this whole discussion. From what has been posted, DaddysProp's Master actively and deliberately had her declared mentally and/or emotionally incompetent. It wasn't an uninvited outside entity that took it upon itself to make a judgment about their relationship. It was her Master (from within the relationship) stating that she is incompetent, thereby stating that she is not able to give consent. At this point her Master has now stated that the relationship is unconsensual. It cannot cut both ways. You can't have on one hand her Master stating that she is incompetent, and then at the same time, saying it is a consensual relationship. This is the crucial point that is getting lost in the melee that is shifting this focus on that point to calling the posters who have raised this concern "do-gooders" and "crusaders" and "white knights." I think it is very dangerous for this point to be lost unless those who are doing so are actually advocating for non-consensual relationships. For example, IrishMist posted about her relationship where she willingly engaged in activities that I personally would consider extreme for myself. However, the key difference is that, from my reading, IrishMist consented in these activities, and I fully support and defend her right to do so. The crucial distinction in DaddysProp case is her relationship, based on her Master's actions in declaring her incompetent, is unconsensual, whereas IrishMist's was consensual. This disctinction is not being imposed by an outside entity, but by DaddysProp's Master....and THAT key fact is what makes this relationship unconsensual.
_____________________________
Aislyn Life is short. bend the rules, forgive quicky, kiss slowly, love truly, laugh uncontrollably, and never regret anything that made you smile.
|